Part of an interesting thread on market completeness on Beyond Microfoundations. I asked:
@David/Keshav,
Is there any proof in general equilibrium theory that, given incomplete markets (say S states of the world, N = S-2 AD securities) a 'non-completing' increase in markets (say to N = S-1 AD securities) invariably results in a Pareto improvement?
Keshav responded:
Rob,
No, in fact an increase in markets (even a `completing' increase) need not be Pareto improving. Here is a counterexample:
There is one commodity (corn), 2 periods and 2 states which are realized between period 0 and 1. There are 3 agents: `savers' who have only a period 0 endowment and value consumption in period 1, state 2 more highly than period 0 consumption; `safe borrowers' who have an endowment in period 1 in either state, and only value period 0 consumption; and `risky borrowers' who only have a period 1, state 2 endowment and only value period 0 consumption. Suppose first that the only asset traded is a riskless bond which pays out one unit of corn in period 1, in either state. The only agent who can issue such a bond is the `safe borrower', since only he can meet his obligation to pay out corn if state 1 occurs.
Now suppose we replace the riskless bond with the two Arrow securities. The security paying off in state 1 will have no value since no-one values state 1 consumption. Now, both types of borrower can issue securities paying out in state 2. Since the supply of these securities is greater than under incomplete markets, their price will be lower. This fall in price reduces the safe borrower's income, so he consumes less in period 0. So completing markets is not Pareto improving.