Bertrand Russell (1946, ch.XXV):
"Ages of prolonged uncertainty, while they are compatible with the highest degree of saintliness in a few, are inimical to the prosaic every-day virtues of respectable citizens. There seems no use in thrift, when tomorrow all your savings may be dissipated; no advantage in honesty, when the man towards whom you practise it is pretty sure to swindle you; no point in steadfast adherence to a cause, when no cause is important or has a chance of stable victory; no argument in favour of truthfulness, when only supple tergiversation makes the preservation of life and fortune possible. The man whose virtue has no source except a purely terrestrial prudence will, in such a world, become an adventurer if he has the courage, and, if not, will seek obscurity as a timid time-server.
. . .fear took the place of hope; the purpose of life was rather to escape misfortune rather than achieve any positive good. 'Metaphysics sink into the background, and ethics, now individual, become of the first importance. Philosophy is no longer the pillar of fire going before a few intrepid seekers after truth: it is rather an ambulance following in the wake of the struggle for existence and picking up the weak and wounded."
01/08/2011
Josef Steindl
As I was continuing my ongoing project to improve Josef Steindl's wikipedia page (eta: end of the summer), I actually bothered to read the introduction to the 1976 reprint of Maturity and Stagnation in American Capitalism. The last 'Postscript' section to this introduction is almost taylor made for today - apparently not much has changed in the past 35 years:
. . .the cooperation between the capitalist powers has broken down - witness their inability to resolve the endemic international currency problem; the internal stresses of groups contending for shares in the national income have shown themselves as inflationary; instead of placating the masses by a steady increase in living standards, the aim has become to dampen their spirits by unemployment, which hits hardest at those who are considered to be the most unruly elements. The arguments against full emloyment have got the upper hand in the councils of the powers, and thus we witness stagnation not as an incomprehensible fate, as in the 1930s, but stagnation as a policy.
19/07/2011
False Dawn
Finally gotten round to starting False Dawn by John Gray (a political book and therefore massively less depressing than Straw Dogs). Good quote, pp38:
Few visions of the future have ever been so delusive as Herbert Marcuse's or Michel Foucault's perenially fashionable vision of perfected capitalist control of society. Late modern capitalism may incarcerate people in high-tech prisons and monitor them by video surveillance cameras at their work-place and in the high street; but it does not box them into an iron cage of bureaucracy or imprison them forever within a minute niche in the division of labour. It abandons them to a life of fragments and a proliferation of senseless choices. The dystopia we face is not a nightmare of totalitarian control. Intermingling the ephemera of fashion with an ingrained reflex of nihilism, American Psycho is a truer approximation to the late modern condition than Kafka's The Castle.
18/07/2011
Amartya Sen
Went to a lecture by Amartya Sen in the New College at Edinburgh this evening. It was an enlightenment lecture, which (disappointingly) didn't address the main current of modern philosophy/history as I understand it, which is that the enlightenment is a failed project. He spoke a lot about Hume's compatibility argument. I don't really think that the compatibility/incompatibility argument makes much sense if you hold a largely Platonic outlook, in that if you believe that there's some sort of underlying structure to reality, it wouldn't really matter if the overlying phenomena that present themselves to us are deterministic or not. Given that most people can't actually agree on what the phenomena are, never mind whether they're deterministic or not, this seems to be a handy fact.
17/07/2011
Dissertation
So dissertation is starting to take form. Its split into two sections, the first is an exposition of monetary theory as it presently stands, the second is an examination of 3 search models of money. The first essentially runs through Woodford's neo-wicksellian monetary theory and how it is anti-quantity theory, then the post-keynesian arguments contra quantity theory and how these have essentially converged (or rather pks have been saying sensible things for decades and the mainstream has, to a small extent, caught up). The question, after the second section, is therefore whether the monetary theory encapsulated in the search models in coherent with the monetary theory presented in the first. The answer to that question is basically yes.
22/06/2011
Bard College (Minsky Seminar)
Currently in my 4th day of the Minsky Summer School at Bard College - so far been absolutely brilliant.
Today we had a guest lecture by Henry Liu, on the reasoning behind his advice to the Chinese government (now incorporated into the latest 5 year plan) to increase wages in China. Absolutely spot on - he didn't put a foot wrong the entire lecture. Some quotes:
Today we had a guest lecture by Henry Liu, on the reasoning behind his advice to the Chinese government (now incorporated into the latest 5 year plan) to increase wages in China. Absolutely spot on - he didn't put a foot wrong the entire lecture. Some quotes:
The fundamental reason wages do not go up is due to global capital [but not global labour], so wage arbitrage keeps wages down . . . I think the problem for the Chinese economy, and the world, is low wages.
The capital - labour relation is a heirarchy, where capital has all the power. This might have been justifiable during the industrial revolution, but capital today is pension funds! So pension fund managers take workers' savings and use them to force their wages down. It's simple.
1932-34 were the only years in history when consumer spending was above 80% of GDP. Consumption is very inelastic.
The global forex market is 15 times the size of global equity markets. If you don't think that's a dangerous situation then you are very optimistic!
Nobody needs reserves when they can issue a fiat currency.
09/06/2011
Results
65% aggregate average. Now we get to start the dissertation (after a summer school at Bard College on Hyman Minsky). My topic is a pseudo-literature review on search-theoretic monetary theory compared with neoclassical monetary theory. Or possibly mainstream Keynesian monetary theory. Who knows. .
14/05/2011
Fordlandia
Had another exam today - panel data. Went fine, better than signalling/screening on Tuesday which was a complete disaster.
Found out today about "Fordlandia", a town in the Brazilian rainforest set up by Henry Ford to provide his factories with a cheap and reliable source of rubber. Needless to say it failed miserably . . . another bizarre episode in the history of capitalism.
Found out today about "Fordlandia", a town in the Brazilian rainforest set up by Henry Ford to provide his factories with a cheap and reliable source of rubber. Needless to say it failed miserably . . . another bizarre episode in the history of capitalism.
08/05/2011
Incidentally, the overall majority now held by the SNP was won despite a PR system that was designed (more or less explicitly) to stop such an event happening. Whilst one of the main arguments of the "No To AV" campaign was that AV systems (read watered down PR) make single party governments less likely. Go figure.
Recent Voting
In more important news, the SNP won a historic victory in MSP elections here in Scotland, and the AV referendum failed completely. So presumably if the Scots start electing SNP MPs as well as MSPs then Labour's vote will be completely destroyed and we face (another) century of Conservative governments. However, if this materialises, given any luck Scotland will manage to leave the union and I'll be able to relinquish British nationality and stay here.
On the plus side, this means Nick Clegg has had to think up something quick to appease recently out-of-office Lib Dem councillors across the UK and he appears to have landed on stopping the NHS being privatised. Which is a good thing.
On the plus side, this means Nick Clegg has had to think up something quick to appease recently out-of-office Lib Dem councillors across the UK and he appears to have landed on stopping the NHS being privatised. Which is a good thing.
01/05/2011
Re Hawkings
Finished A Brief History of Time. One week to go until first exams, and then nine exams in two weeks. Was thinking, this morning, in the spirit of Hawking's point about memorising being an entropy-increasing process, that measuring time itself (by a clock) is also entropy-increasing in the sense that powering a digital clock (for example) also results in a dissipation of heat (but not as much as a computer).
27/04/2011
So the below points towards an imprecise set of microfoundations for the older generation of simultaneous equation models not derived from an intertemporal consumption/saving optimisation problem. Consumption and investment decisions are separated, essentially, allowing for a return to the Kalecki/Goodwin worker/capitalist models. Obviously, if savings are only allowed to take the form of equity then this distinction effectively holds anyway. The problem, of course, is how to reconcile the consumption and saving decision (in a form as close to the neoclassical method as possible) with the now independent investment decision. There is an enormous amount of literature for inspiration, fortunately.
26/04/2011
I => S etc
Thoughts whilst reading Chiang's Fundamental Methods of Mathematical Economics chapter on dynamic analysis. Really need to work through this whole book next year (as I'm rubbish at maths):
In neoclassical dynamic equilibrium models, I = S is decided by an optimal intertemporal consumption decision give accessible rates of return on S => I. With the existence of firms, if owners can communicate their chosen level of investment, nothings changes. Alternatively, if this communication is impossible for whatever reason, shareholders can communicate these decisions through efficient capital markets (by Modigliani Miller).
However, if both production and financial intermediation exist, there is no mechanism by which the system can ensure S => I from max u(C) problem (see argument contra MM). In this world, clearly investment may be induced to a degree dependent on firms' behaviour; ie we get multiplier-accelerator dynamics and I <=> S (see Chiang pp540 for Samuelson M-A model).
Alternatively, the Lucas surprise supply model is essentially an induced investment model based on noise in firms' demand (see Fisher Black's paper, Noise)!! 'Noise' models with irreversible processes should, incidentally, provide lots of material for simulated disequilibrium macro-models. . .
In neoclassical dynamic equilibrium models, I = S is decided by an optimal intertemporal consumption decision give accessible rates of return on S => I. With the existence of firms, if owners can communicate their chosen level of investment, nothings changes. Alternatively, if this communication is impossible for whatever reason, shareholders can communicate these decisions through efficient capital markets (by Modigliani Miller).
However, if both production and financial intermediation exist, there is no mechanism by which the system can ensure S => I from max u(C) problem (see argument contra MM). In this world, clearly investment may be induced to a degree dependent on firms' behaviour; ie we get multiplier-accelerator dynamics and I <=> S (see Chiang pp540 for Samuelson M-A model).
Alternatively, the Lucas surprise supply model is essentially an induced investment model based on noise in firms' demand (see Fisher Black's paper, Noise)!! 'Noise' models with irreversible processes should, incidentally, provide lots of material for simulated disequilibrium macro-models. . .
Stephen Hawking . . .
Re-reading A Brief History of Time for the nth time (probably the best book ever). Ch.9:
A computer memory is basically a device consisting of elements that can exist in either of two states. Before an item is recorded in a computer's memory, the memory is in a disordered state, with equal probabilities for the two possible states. After the memory interacts with the system to be remembered, it will definitely be in one state or the other, according to the state of the system. So the memory has passed from a disordered state to an ordered state. However, in order to make sure that the memory is in the right state, it is necesssary to use a certain amount of energy. This energy is dissipated as heat, and increases the amout of disorder in the universe. One can show that this increase in disorder is always greater than the increase in the order of the memory itself. Thus the heat expelled by the computer's cooling fan means that when a computer records an item in memory, the total amout of disorder in the universe still goes up. The direction of time in which a computer remembers the past is the same as that in which disorder increases.
Our subjective sense of the direction of time, the psychological arrow of time, is therefore determined within our brain by the thermodynamic arrow of time. Just as a computer, we must remember things in the order in which entropy increases. This makes the second law of thermodynamics almost trivial. Disorder increases with time because we measure time in the direction in which disorder increases. You can't have a safer bet than that!
20/04/2011
Milton Friedman, FT interview 2003
"I've been wrong so far, so I don't have too much confidence in my view. But I think within the next 10 to 15 years the eurozone will split apart. The British government, on balance, should stay out of it."
The Heart of the Matter
Also, finished The Heart of the Matter over the weekend. Quite possibly the most depressing book I've ever read - not existentially depressing in the continental manner, more heavy and oppressive in a more emotional sense. Good though - now I just want to read more GG. .
'Market Completing'
Part of an interesting thread on market completeness on Beyond Microfoundations. I asked:
@David/Keshav,Keshav responded:
Is there any proof in general equilibrium theory that, given incomplete markets (say S states of the world, N = S-2 AD securities) a 'non-completing' increase in markets (say to N = S-1 AD securities) invariably results in a Pareto improvement?
Rob,
No, in fact an increase in markets (even a `completing' increase) need not be Pareto improving. Here is a counterexample:
There is one commodity (corn), 2 periods and 2 states which are realized between period 0 and 1. There are 3 agents: `savers' who have only a period 0 endowment and value consumption in period 1, state 2 more highly than period 0 consumption; `safe borrowers' who have an endowment in period 1 in either state, and only value period 0 consumption; and `risky borrowers' who only have a period 1, state 2 endowment and only value period 0 consumption. Suppose first that the only asset traded is a riskless bond which pays out one unit of corn in period 1, in either state. The only agent who can issue such a bond is the `safe borrower', since only he can meet his obligation to pay out corn if state 1 occurs.
Now suppose we replace the riskless bond with the two Arrow securities. The security paying off in state 1 will have no value since no-one values state 1 consumption. Now, both types of borrower can issue securities paying out in state 2. Since the supply of these securities is greater than under incomplete markets, their price will be lower. This fall in price reduces the safe borrower's income, so he consumes less in period 0. So completing markets is not Pareto improving.
16/04/2011
Irreversible Changes
"Entropy measures the irreversible changes in a system"
Equilibrium = maximum entropy; in an economic system in equilbrium, all possible irreversible processes have been completed. SELF ORGANIZATION is order in non-equilibrium states - where entropy inside a
system is lowered by increasing entropy increase outside the system (thus net entropy increases) . . . this cannot be examined using equilibrium mechanics.
See Sethi (2006) Statistical Mechanics: Entropy, Order Parameters, and Complexity. Thanks to a lecture handout on graphical models here.
I will now stop talking about things I don't understand for a while and put down sensible posts.
Equilibrium = maximum entropy; in an economic system in equilbrium, all possible irreversible processes have been completed. SELF ORGANIZATION is order in non-equilibrium states - where entropy inside a
system is lowered by increasing entropy increase outside the system (thus net entropy increases) . . . this cannot be examined using equilibrium mechanics.
See Sethi (2006) Statistical Mechanics: Entropy, Order Parameters, and Complexity. Thanks to a lecture handout on graphical models here.
I will now stop talking about things I don't understand for a while and put down sensible posts.
14/04/2011
Idea
For PhD as my proposals stand irt solving search models with microscopic simulation:
Things needed prior to completing the above:
- Define a lattice and relevant objects (agents)
- Allow searching agents to randomly change location every period; this will give an ex ante objective probability distribution to finding other agents (trade opportunities, jobs) based on relation of searching agents to non-searching agents to lattice size etc
- Use the above method to estimate an analytically tractable search model (eg basic job-search in Pissarides (2000))
Things needed prior to completing the above:
Learn search-theory- Learn object-oriented programming
- Take classes in combinatorics
13/04/2011
Larry Summers & Martin Wolf, INET Conference
Two brilliant passages from Larry Summers, being interviewed by Martin Wolf at the 2011 INET conference at Bretton Woods (thanks to beyondmicrofoundations for pointing out the video):
"We have a broad social problem that covers everything from finance to deep sea drilling to nuclear, that in all kinds of areas that are technical and hugely important to society, there is roughly nobody who knows about them who does not also have some sort of deep interest in them, and that creates all kinds of questions of legitimacy and knowledge, in that we don’t want regulation by the co-opted, but nor do we want regulation by the ignorant . . . there is hardly anybody who is both knowledgeable and uncoopted."
"I find the idea of ‘expansionary fiscal contraction’ in the context of the world in which we now live, to be every bit as oxymoronic as it sounds, and I think the consequences are likely to be very serious for the countries involved . . . but I’ve always been a believer in being an empiricist about my convictions, so I would be happy to say that if Britain enjoys a boom over the next two years coming from increased confidence I would be required to radically re-think my view as to how the macroeconomy operates and to be quite contrite about the seriousness of my misjudgement. You can make a judgement, those of you who know me, how likely I would be to put myself in a position of great contrition, and you might therefore conclude that I am fairly confident this experiment is unlikely to work out well!"
Normal Distribution
Yesterday evening I found out that the normal distribution was discovered/invented by Gauss in order to justify the OLS method. It was then shown to be the maximum entropy distribution for any distribution with a given mean and variance, the central limit theorem was proved, &c, and then found its way into theoretical physics (as any gas in equilibrium is in its maximum entropy state, the particles' velocities must be normally distributed as this the m.e.d.). The history of science is full of wierd stories like this! I think Feyerabend would have enjoyed it . . . I'm personally still quite attached to a 'logic of scientific discovery', however . . .
12/04/2011
Re below before econometrics. . .
Schroedinger's view on the matter below is that life is a 'process of negative entropy' - living structures take in energy from their surroundings to maintain internal order. Life, in this sense, emerging from inanimate matter at some point is a non-life process of decreasing entropy. Gravity as well would seem to perform the trick - the creation of stars and heavy elements within stars via nuclear fusion etc, the creation of galaxies and so on. . .
11/04/2011
Emergent Computing
Agent-based modelling is a fairly new area of research in economics (economics is a bit behind the times compared to physics or biology here), and is something I'd like to look at (hopefully) during PhD study next year. Its fairly obviously related to cellular automata, in which can arise a phenomenon called "emergent computation" - decentralized information processing at a global level. This kind of thing sounds very similar to the Austrian assertion that markets are essentially information-processors, and that 'the market' can create an allocation based on information that no agent individually possesses. In other words, Austrian economists claimed that decentralized social systems should exhibit emergent computation - something that might be demonstrable with agent-based modelling. This is obviously going on faith - I currently don't know anything about cellular automata.
People to read re this:
People to read re this:
- Melanie Mitchell at Sante Fe
- A New Kind of Science, Stephen Wolfram
- Cellular Automata, Andrew Ilachinski
Statistics, Sociology, Physics
Had a read of the "Statistics and Physical Theories" chapter by Theodore Porter in The Cambridge History of Science (vol 5) today as some relief from adverse selection/signalling/screening models. I found it near why I was sitting in the library and I've been recently talking to an art historian friend, Ruth Harriss, about this kind of thing in relation to Xenakis's philosophy of music (more to follow on this later).
It's quite an interesting chapter - he points out that statistics as a subject area was originally a human science, attached to census analysis &c and only gradually became attached to probability theory before being used in statistical physics (the etymology of 'statistics' is statisticum collegium: 'council of state'). He also talks for a while about the history of statistical regularities being seen as synonymous with 'social laws', and arguments over the impossibility of human agency in the face of such regularities through the 19th century.
More interesting, however, is the section Reversibility, Recurrence and the Direction of Time where the "reversibility paradox" is discussed. The reversibility paradox is that, under the statistical physics interpretation, the second law of thermodynamics (law of increase in entropy in an isolated system) is based purely on the fact that high entropy states are more probable than low entropy states. In which case there is always a small but positive probability that entropy might spontaneously decrease in a given system. The recurrence paradox is that any ergodic system should eventually return very nearly to their original state - again, suggesting that entropy should at some point (however far in the future) decrease. A spontaneous decrease in entropy is never observed however - hence the paradox.
This also raises more philosophical problems, as the law of entropy increase is the physical basis for an 'arrow of time':
This, of course, is all pre-Big Bang theory, and pre-Schroedinger's definition of life as a process of 'negative entropy'. Lastly, Porter repeats Boltzmann's point that even a small volume of gas would only separate into hydrogen and oxygen about once in (10^10)^10 years.
It's quite an interesting chapter - he points out that statistics as a subject area was originally a human science, attached to census analysis &c and only gradually became attached to probability theory before being used in statistical physics (the etymology of 'statistics' is statisticum collegium: 'council of state'). He also talks for a while about the history of statistical regularities being seen as synonymous with 'social laws', and arguments over the impossibility of human agency in the face of such regularities through the 19th century.
More interesting, however, is the section Reversibility, Recurrence and the Direction of Time where the "reversibility paradox" is discussed. The reversibility paradox is that, under the statistical physics interpretation, the second law of thermodynamics (law of increase in entropy in an isolated system) is based purely on the fact that high entropy states are more probable than low entropy states. In which case there is always a small but positive probability that entropy might spontaneously decrease in a given system. The recurrence paradox is that any ergodic system should eventually return very nearly to their original state - again, suggesting that entropy should at some point (however far in the future) decrease. A spontaneous decrease in entropy is never observed however - hence the paradox.
This also raises more philosophical problems, as the law of entropy increase is the physical basis for an 'arrow of time':
"Perhaps the universe simply began in an extremely improbable state. Possibly, however, it is so huge that from time to time vast areas of it fluctuate by chance into highly improbable states. These define the conditions in which life is possible . . . Or perhaps our experience of the direction of time is defined by increasing entropy."
This, of course, is all pre-Big Bang theory, and pre-Schroedinger's definition of life as a process of 'negative entropy'. Lastly, Porter repeats Boltzmann's point that even a small volume of gas would only separate into hydrogen and oxygen about once in (10^10)^10 years.
09/04/2011
Things achieved this week
- Most of the revision I wanted to get done. Have a new-found respect for Lucas's 'surprise-supply' model.
- Read half of The Heart of the Matter.
- Saw Beethoven's 4th piano concerto amongst other not-so-good things at Usher Hall. Never sure if 'saw' is the correct verb in this situation.
- Am about to go and see The Silent House.
- Reconfirmed my intense hatred of DSGE models. Apart from the fact that they bore me sh*tless, it makes no sense whatsoever to analyse economic dynamics using an immanent-equilibrium model. Whatever happened to the post-socialist calculation debate (post-Hayek, basically) philosophy of value theory as value theory, rather than an actual applicable tool? I'm not bothered by the general equilibrium approach per se, and therefore can appreciate the theoretical interest in DGE models and other sequential equilibrium approaches. But constructing a model that represents the logical conclusion of a competitive process at every moment in time and then pertubing bits of it with random shocks in an attempt to model historical dynamics is an absurd thing to do. It's like modelling the universe at heat-death and assuming it describes the present (maybe this is a slight overstatement. . .)
Point me out the happy man and I will point you out either egotism, selfishness, evil - or else an absolute ignorance.
If one knew, he wondered, the facts, would one have to feel pity even for the planets? if one reached what they called the heart of the matter?
- Book 2 pt1 ch2
05/04/2011
Wirtschaftsring
Things I have achieved today:
This discovery fits in quite well with my current view of what monetary reform can and can't change. There is a persistent view amongst economists that controlling the money supply can in some way control the economy - from 100% reserve banking (Frederick Soddy via Henry Simons & the Chicago School) to monetarism. In these theories, control of the money supply allows real activity to be curtailed. Henry Simons later concluded that monetary reform and control cannot hinder activity, as near-monies fill the gap between demand and supply (eg the Wir, or factory currencies in England during the industrial revolution). It seems fair to say that reform can encourage activity, however, by stabilising credit supply for certain subsets of agents (by establishing not-for-profit institutions) or by supplying funds that private money markets cannot (due to short-termism, for example). An example of the latter is the EU investment bank, whose shareholders are the EU member states. The UK is setting up a 'Green Investment Bank', but there's no reason why such an institution couldn't be set-up to provide financing for SMEs, or mortgages, or regional infrastructure . . .&c.
- Some price theory revision
- Discovered the Wirtschaftsring (Economic Circle)
This discovery fits in quite well with my current view of what monetary reform can and can't change. There is a persistent view amongst economists that controlling the money supply can in some way control the economy - from 100% reserve banking (Frederick Soddy via Henry Simons & the Chicago School) to monetarism. In these theories, control of the money supply allows real activity to be curtailed. Henry Simons later concluded that monetary reform and control cannot hinder activity, as near-monies fill the gap between demand and supply (eg the Wir, or factory currencies in England during the industrial revolution). It seems fair to say that reform can encourage activity, however, by stabilising credit supply for certain subsets of agents (by establishing not-for-profit institutions) or by supplying funds that private money markets cannot (due to short-termism, for example). An example of the latter is the EU investment bank, whose shareholders are the EU member states. The UK is setting up a 'Green Investment Bank', but there's no reason why such an institution couldn't be set-up to provide financing for SMEs, or mortgages, or regional infrastructure . . .&c.
04/04/2011
First Post
So this is my first post. A bit of a strange time to start a blog, seeing as I'm just about to sit MSc examinations (in economics), so you'd think I'd have better things to do. Some things about me:
The future is already here - it's just not very evenly distributed
- William Gibson
- I'm an MSc economics student at Edinburgh, planning to continue to PhD in September.
- I've started a blog because I think it might help me to write notes and thoughts down in a manner which is actually intelligible. None of my notebooks make any sense.
- Will this actually help?
- Do blog posts follow a poisson process?
The future is already here - it's just not very evenly distributed
- William Gibson
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)