19/07/2011

False Dawn

Finally gotten round to starting False Dawn by John Gray (a political book and therefore massively less depressing than Straw Dogs).  Good quote, pp38:
Few visions of the future have ever been so delusive as Herbert Marcuse's or Michel Foucault's perenially fashionable vision of perfected capitalist control of society.  Late modern capitalism may incarcerate people in high-tech prisons and monitor them by video surveillance cameras at their work-place and in the high street; but it does not box them into an iron cage of bureaucracy or imprison them  forever within a minute niche in the division of labour.  It abandons them to a life of fragments and a proliferation of senseless choices.  The dystopia we face is not a nightmare of totalitarian control.  Intermingling the ephemera of fashion with an ingrained reflex of nihilism, American Psycho is a truer approximation to the late modern condition than Kafka's The Castle.

18/07/2011

Amartya Sen

Went to a lecture by Amartya Sen in the New College at Edinburgh this evening.  It was an enlightenment lecture, which (disappointingly) didn't address the main current of modern philosophy/history as I understand it, which is that the enlightenment is a failed project.  He spoke a lot about Hume's compatibility argument.  I don't really think that the compatibility/incompatibility argument makes much sense if you hold a largely Platonic outlook, in that if you believe that there's some sort of underlying structure to reality, it wouldn't really matter if the overlying phenomena that present themselves to us are deterministic or not.  Given that most people can't actually agree on what the phenomena are, never mind whether they're deterministic or not, this seems to be a handy fact.

17/07/2011

Dissertation

So dissertation is starting to take form.  Its split into two sections, the first is an exposition of monetary theory as it presently stands, the second is an examination of 3 search models of money.  The first essentially runs through Woodford's neo-wicksellian monetary theory and how it is anti-quantity theory, then the post-keynesian arguments contra quantity theory and how these have essentially converged (or rather pks have been saying sensible things for decades and the mainstream has, to a small extent, caught up).  The question, after the second section, is therefore whether the monetary theory encapsulated in the search models in coherent with the monetary theory presented in the first.  The answer to that question is basically yes.